|
MEDIA IGNORES CRISIS: MASS RAPES
IN BOSNIA AREN'T SEXY ANY MORE, THEY'RE JUST TRAGIC
By Linda Grant
August 9, 1993 (The Record Waterloo,
Ontario) Eight months ago, in a maternity hospital in Zagreb, a
British journalist and a French camera crew degenerated into an
undignified tussle over the bed of a teenage girl who was pregnant
after being raped by a Serbian.
The media was desperate for rape babies. Rape in Bosnia was the
hottest story of the new year. The city was teeming with foreign
journalists, scouring refugee camps with a revival of that familiar
wartime phrase: "Anyone here been raped and speak English?"
The European Commission investigation into the allegations of mass
rape, led by retired Bristish diplomat Dame Anne Warburton, concluded
that around 20,000 women had suffered sexual assault at the hands
of Serbian forces and the mission gave credence to the claim that
rape was being used as a systematic weapon in the campaign of ethnic
cleansing. There were demands by women's organizations that rape
be included as a war crime within the Geneva Convention.
Then the hospitals of Zagreb and Sarajevo did not fill with abandoned
infants and the media lost interest. No one was able to come up
with any reliable figure for the numbers of women actually raped.
At least one member of the EC mission, who was originally convinced
that rape was part of the ethnic cleansing program, is now more
skeptical. Ironically, these doubts have crept in because some aid
agencies have begun to admit privately that rape has always been
part of the spoils of war. If rape became an international issue
in Bosnia, it is because it is the first war that has been monitored
by a well-organized, modern women's movement.
Even the allegation of rape camps now seems contentious. Certainly,
women were raped in general prisoner of war camps. But no one has
produced hard evidence of special installations established to impregnate
Bosnian women with Serbian babies.
What seems more likely is that Serbian paramilitaries would move
into an area and establish a base in a village. A number of women
would be rounded up and held in a motel or restaurant which would
be used as an enforced brothel by soldiers tanked up on drugs after
a hard day's killing and torture. When the Serbians moved on, after
a few weeks, the women would be murdered or released according to
no clear pattern.
The reason for the lack of rape babies is obvious. Only women who
have been held over a period of months would be forced to bring
a child to full term. Abortion on demand is available in Bosnia
up to 10 weeks, in Croatia up to 12. Most raped pregnant women would
have had abortions without having to notify anyone of the cause
of the pregnancy.
However, arguing about how many women have been raped and why it
was done has overshadowed another issue: what has happened to the
women since their ordeal ended?
In Zagreb, there is a growing number of reports of suicide and attempted
suicide among female Bosnian refugees. The stigma associated with
rape in a country that has never had a rape counselling service
means the most likely way for women to receive help is if they have
developed general psychiatric problems. Other women have been referred
by their families after two psychiatrists went on a local radio
phone-in.
"We have women who have been raped and diagnosed as having
post-traumatic stress disorders - nightmares, manic depression -
and they don't want to talk about what happened to them. They feel
they are somehow guilty themselves," say Dr. Vera Folnegovic
and Dr. Dragica Kozaric-Kovacic, at Zagreb's Rebro Psychiatric Hospital.
For them, the numbers game is irrelevant: "We have one or two
women who were raped eight or nine times a day for five months.
Is this one case or hundreds?" Getting the women to come forward
is another matter. In January, Croatia officially had 288,000 Bosnian
refugees, of which 111,000 lived with families rather than in refugee
camps where there are aid workers to listen to testimonies.
Some are presenting themselves at casualty departments with what
psychiatrists regard as psychosomatic symptoms such as high blood
pressure and irregular heartbeats. It is only during medical examinations
that they admit they were raped. Yet earlier this year, the Croatian
government announced that Bosnian refugees would no longer receive
free medical treatment.
There is only one reported case of a woman resuming sexual relations
with her husband and she told psychiatrists it was "like being
killed, she didn't know if the emotional pain was worse than the
physical pain and there was no reason for physical pain," Folnegovic
says.
The future for young girls who were virgins before they were raped
is even grimmer: "They don't want to see men, any men. Their
sexual function is completely destroyed and it's very hard to tell
if they will ever have a normal sex life. They all need psychiatric
support," says Folnegovic.
A debate has been raging about what should happen to the raped women
of Bosnia. Women's groups in Zagreb want to set up a special hostel
where they could receive long-term counselling.
Specialists in war trauma, however, argue that rape as a specific
issue will become an acute problem only after the conflict is over
and people are no longer in survival mode. The Muslim community
believes special hostels will identify and stigmatize the women.
In one refugee camp I visited in January, the activists seemed to
be educated women who had committed themselves to a more fundamentalist
Islam than that practised loosely by the peasant Muslim population.
It was these women who were organizing groups within the camps and
to whom raped women were sharing the secret of their ordeal.
One of the recommendations of the EC mission was for money to be
made available to set up rape counselling services. The money was
snapped up by the British organization Marie Stopes Society which
has two teams currently trying to establish bases within Bosnia,
at Tuzla and Zenica.
The Marie Stopes teams' aims are to help existing groups and deliver
resources and training. Like everyone else, they have no idea of
the numbers of raped women they may find. "One can only speculate
and it's dangerous to speculate," says Paul Anticoni, the London
co-ordinator of the Marie Stopes Bosnia project. "There may
be one, there may be thousands. What we do know is that there is
a severe lack of trauma counselling, as a result of the breakdown
of infrastructure, as well as a lack of trained personnel. A large
number of individuals will have taken it on themselves to establish
self-help groups. There's a lot of prostitution and a degradation
of the social order. We're trying to identify the problems and see
what kind of support is needed."
This makes pretty dull reading. There is something sexy, in media
terms, about thousands of pretty Muslim virgins sobbing out their
tales of sexual violation: "The 15-year-old pulled her thin
blouse over her full breasts and said, "The Chetnik penetrated
me many times'," was the general quality of the news reporting
in January. When there are no more weeping girls the long-term fate
of a traumatized nation becomes substantially less worthy of media
attention.
Linda Grant writes for the Guardian in London.
|