PAKISTAN:Small Loans Pull Women Out of Poverty
Trap
by Zofeen T. Ebrahim
December 5, 2005 - (IPS) A small loan of
8,000 rupees, about 160 dollars, has enabled 35-year-old seamstress
Laila to expand her business and escape the glass ceiling of rural
Pakistan's patriarchal culture.
Although they live in a village deep
in the interior of Sindh province, 225 km from the port city of
Karachi, her family has bought a refrigerator, TV, computer, dining
set, electric fans and furniture with her earnings. "Earlier
we had nothing. Even providing three meals a day was not easy,"
she says.
Now Laila is the decision-maker in
her family and village. Over the last two years she has helped form
eight new self-help groups of up to eight women each in her village,
Bhit Shah.
Her husband's earnings go to pay for
the installments on two small plots of land the family recently
bought. He "often calls me the big boss," she admits laughingly.
Says Hura, her 22-year-old daughter: "I'd never see my mother
smile so much and so often."
The mammoth changes in her life were
brought about by the Sindh Agricultural and Forestry Workers Coordinating
Organisation (Safwco). In 2004, she joined the ranks of some 6,500
people who have taken loans in four sub-districts of Sanghar under
its microfinance programme. Between 2001 and 2004, Safwco was a
partner in the Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund, an umbrella group
sponsored by the Pakistan government and funded by the World Bank.
A vast majority of Pakistan's people
are poor. According to the Asian Development Bank, an estimated
32.1 percent of the population lives below the poverty line. Two-thirds
of the country's 162 million people live in the villages. Only a
fraction have access to the small loans of microfinance programmes.
What Pakistan needs is a "pro-poor
macroeconomic policy", says Kaiser Bengali, of the Social Policy
Development Centre here. Microcredit, he argues, is no panacea for
poverty. The United Nations has designated 2005 the International
Year of Microcredit.
"While it is always good to see
someone who has benefited from a programme, microfinance can be
an added tool to deal with poverty," he says. "Poverty
reduction is a collective issue, and benefiting a few individuals
is not a substitute for dealing with mass poverty."
According to Bengali, provision of
education, adequate health services and appropriate infrastructure
support -- services which are the responsibility of the state --
have to be included in the fight against poverty.
Political economist Asad Sayeed advises
that if money for microfinance were channeled into public works
"it would be a better way to do it".
Microfinance may not be the perfect
cure for poverty, but it has provided much-needed insight into the
lives of the poor.
It has proved without doubt that the
poor are capable of saving, maybe not in the conventional manner,
as their investments are in the form of purchased assets, such as
gold jewelry, livestock and land. Their idea of saving is to be
able to get ready cash in times of emergency.
Access to small loans has made the
dips and peaks of poverty less pronounced by giving the poor the
opportunity to start businesses, pay for school fees, procure housing
or receive health care. It is also seen as a direct way to tackle
Millennium Development Goal 1, fighting poverty and hunger, and
Goal 3, promoting gender equality and empowering women.
The eight MDGs were established by
the UN General Assembly in 2000, with the main goal being to halve
the proportion of the world's population living on less than one
dollar a day by 2015.
To the few who have been able to avail
themselves of microfinance, it has given them an opportunity and
choice. These small loans have meant a difference between everyday
fights for survival and going to sleep at night with a full stomach.
For people like Dungar Mal, one of
the best cobblers in the town of Shahdadpur, and who lost everything
in the four years that he was sick, it was an opportunity to start
again.
Because the poor cannot access traditional
formal financial institutions, a majority of them depend upon the
informal credit market for which they pay very high interest rates.
Thanks to microfinance opportunities, the dependency of the poor
on other expensive sources of credit has been reduced.
Take Bashiran, for example, who buys
second-hand clothing from Karachi and repairs, alters and then sells
them in small towns and villages in Sindh. She says she "is
alive again". She says the worry lines on her face "have
all but vanished" as she has finally got rid of the "burly
Pathan" money lenders who were forever knocking on her door.
Her profits have quadrupled and all
her children are going to school. And, she adds proudly, now when
her guests want to use the toilet, she can take them to her newly
constructed latrine "that does not stink."
Another happy story is that of Sakina
Bughio. She sells milk from the six buffaloes and one cow she has
taken on hire. The profits have enabled her to buy the three calves
that were born from her hired livestock. "I'll feed them for
four to five years before they start giving milk. And in between
if there is an emergency, God forbid, I know I can always sell one
of these as they are mine."
In Pakistan, like elsewhere, microfinance
has shattered the myth that the poor do not repay their debts. In
fact, they pay up the high interest rates to assure long-term access
to credit. The alternative -- an even higher interest rate from
the informal finance sector or money lenders, or outright refusal
by the commercial banks -- is far less attractive.
The small loans have transformed lives
beyond expectations.
Sakina has been twice elected the local
councilor and Sanhul, who earned a livelihood making patchwork quilts,
has bought a cow with the loan from Safwco.
http://www.ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=31290
|