|
Checklist of Key Gender Dimensions for Iraq by
Sector
Compiled by UNIFEM for UNDG
June 2003
Security Council resolution 1483 recognizes the
importance of gender in the reconstruction of Iraq, and recalls
Security Council resolution 1325 on Women, Peace and Security, which
makes womens human rights and a gender perspective relevant
to negotiating peace agreements, planning humanitarian assistance
and peacekeeping operations and reconstructing war-torn societies,
from planning and assessment through to the withdrawal phase. Gender
mainstreaming must start from the very beginning of a mission to
ensure that structures and programmes are designed to address the
different requirements of women and men for protection, assistance,
justice and reconstruction.
In order to ensure that the gender components of all elements of
the peace-building and recovery process are identified and mainstreamed
into planning procedures and programme implementation, the following
checklists have been developed for those participating in assessment
and fact finding missions to Iraq. The questions noted below were
adapted or directly taken from United Nations resources, including
those produced by UNESCO, UNFPA, UNICEF, UNDP, WFP, OHCHR, the Office
of the Special Advisor on Gender Issues and the Advancement of Women
and UNIFEM. Specific resources available outside the UN system have
been cited.
1. General and Cross-Cutting Issues
A. How have men and women, girls and boys been affected differently
by the conflict? Have women and men been affected differently by
specific events such as the destruction of schools, roads, sanitation
facilities, markets, homes, etc.?
B. What are the different coping mechanisms used by men, women,
girls and boys? What resources/supports are they using to survive?
Are these in jeopardy or over-stretched? Why?
C. Do women have equal access to resources for recovery and reconstruction
(human, technical, financial)? What would help increase their access
to resources?
D. What specific power structures can be identified within communities?
What are the specific threats or risks facing women and girls in
the current environment? What can be done to remove these threats
or minimize them in the immediate, medium, and long-term? Threats
could include increased violence including domestic violence, marginalization
in the political realm/exclusion from political processes related
to peace building, etc.
E. What are the prevailing attitudes, religious and cultural norms
and practices that affect women's ability to contribute to and benefit
from recovery and reconstruction efforts? How can we ensure that
these attitudes, norms and practices are not a barrier to women
and girls' enjoying equal access to resources, opportunities, education,
etc.?
F. Are women involved in decision-making, including at the highest
levels? What specific steps can be taken to increase their involvement?
What barriers prevent women and girls from meaningful participation
and involvement in decision-making?
G. What programmes are in place to prevent and respond to violence,
abuse and exploitation against women and girls? Do these programmes
involve the community, men and women, to respond to and support
survivors? Are assistance programmes monitored to prevent exploitation
and abuse of women and girls? Are there shelters and services for
women and girls, particularly those who are displaced, unaccompanied
or abused? What mechanisms for effective prevention and response
with regard to sexual abuse and exploitation as well as in general
any other womens rights abuse can be highlighted within UN
activities?
H. Do leadership training and capacity building programmes for womens
groups already exist? How are women organizing in their communities
and in society at large? Are networks emerging among civil society
groups, particularly among womens organizations?
I. How are different roles, strategies, responsibilities and options
of women, men and adolescents affected in unstable situations? How
have these changed over the past ten years and during the current
period of instability?
J. Has there been a disparate impact on women from different sectors
within the society? Does the context in which women find themselves,
such as urban or rural location, individual ethnicity or religion
affect gender relations in a particular area?
K. What data and analysis is available for each sector? Is it disaggregated
by sex and age?
L. How can information be gathered and disaggregated to account
for widows and female-headed households who may account for a larger
proportion of the population
during and after conflict?
M. How have men and women, boys and girls been affected differently
by displacement during the conflict? Are the specific needs of returning
men and women, especially female heads of household, being addressed?
Will refugee women with few resources, some living on a basic subsistence,
have the ability to return? To what extent will women make decisions
regarding return and what factors will be most critical to making
these decisions? How will this information be provided to refugee
communities in neighboring countries?
N. Is there equal access for boys and girls to safe and secure opportunities
for stimulation and non-violent social interactions?
O. How has the current response by the international community addressed
the gender dimensions of recovery and reconstruction? Are equal
numbers of women and men being hired (or trained) for both international
and national staff positions in recovery and reconstruction efforts?
What can be done to further strengthen gender mainstreaming during
planning, implementation, monitoring and evaluation?
P. Is there gender balance on the needs assessment team, and has
a gender focal point been designated to monitor and provide technical
support to the needs assessment team?
2. Primary Education
A. Are there equal numbers of males and females teachers, administrators
and other leaders in education among the population that is destabilized?
How can they take leadership roles in creating and sustaining the
education of girls and boys during crisis?
B. What are additional specific barriers to learning in the current
unstable environment? How are these different for girls and boys?
What factors account for this trend? How can the education system
track and remedy this trend?
C. What actions are in place to accommodate the education needs
of disabled, orphaned, separated or otherwise unaccompanied girls?
D. How do alternative or informal models of education accommodate
the different vulnerabilities and changed roles and responsibilities
of girls and boys in the current situation?
E. Are education programs available for drug abuse, and prevention
of sexually transmitted infections (STI), including HIV/AIDS particularly
for girls?
F. Are women and girls able to travel to school safely?
3. Higher Education
A. Are there equal numbers of males and females teachers, administrators
and other leaders in education among the population that is destabilized?
How can educators take leadership roles in creating and sustaining
the education of girls and boys during crisis?
B. Are education programs available for drug abuse, and prevention
of sexually transmitted infections (STI), including HIV/AIDS particularly
for adolescents?
C. Are women and girls able to travel to secondary school safely?
4. Health and Nutrition
A. What impact does the burden of care have on womens time
use and how can assistance in the health sector address this critical
obstacle to womens mobility, access to resources and education?
B. How are women health workers engaged in disseminating information
about and improving access to immunization services?
C. Are there reproductive health services in hospitals, clinics
and other health facilities for men, women and adolescents?
D. To what extent do health workers receive gender-sensitive reproductive
health training?
E. Has the breakdown in law and order that often accompanies conflict
had and impact on womens vulnerability and exposure to gender
based violence?
F. What mechanisms are in place to address gender-based violence?
Is awareness training provided to international and local relief
staff, including in the areas of detection, referral and counseling?
To what extent are services available, including shelters for victims
of sexual abuse?
G. Do military personnel receive training on gender-based violence
and human rights?
H. Are there gaps in providing integrated health services to women,
men and adolescents, particularly in the area of reproductive health?
I. What programmes are available to address psychosocial needs of
the community, particularly for women and girls?
J. Are HIV/AIDS testing facilities available in the country for
civilians and for international staff?
K. Are boys and girls equally nourished ? How are feeding practices
changed to meet the emergency situation?
L. How has the presence of military and other combatants placed
men and women at greater risk for human rights violations, including
gender-based violence?. How will demobilization impact on men and
womens health and livelihoods?
5. Water Supply and Sanitation
The Asia Development Bank checklist on water and sanitation provides
a comprehensive and well-constructed module for considering the
gender dimensions of this sector. This module should be used for
needs assessments in this sector. http://www.adb.org/Documents/Manuals/Gender_Checklists/Water/gender_checklist_water.pdf
A. What are the constraints to women and men, girls and boys in
having access to appropriate water and sanitation facilities, water
quality, water quantity, reliability, distance from source, distance
from latrines, appropriate technology, maintenance, cultural acceptability?
B. Have feminine hygiene needs been addressed? .
6. Telecommunications
A. What access to women have to media programmes, in terms of production,
dissemination and access to information?
7. Agriculture and Food Security
A. Are power structures at work in the community in relation to
the use of food? Can food be used as a weapon or only to benefit
certain groups? What are the different roles of women and men in
food management at the household level? Who receives food aid on
behalf of the family and are women or men more likely to prioritize
family sustenance over individual survival? Can ration cards be
issued in the name of women in order to strengthen their control
over food?
B. How do gender, age and other disparities between and within groups
relate to individuals' vulnerability to food insecurity? .
C. How much and what kind of food do women, men and children have
access to? How much do they need? How do they obtain food and when
and why do gaps between need and consumption occur?
D. What are people's coping strategies? Are some coping strategies
unsustainable?
E. What are the indicators of food security and development? Is
information gathered for indicators sex disaggregated, especially
as assessments will inform the intervention?
8. Local Governance and Community Driven Development and Governance
and Public Management (Justice, Rule of Law, Civil Service)
A. Will the emerging political system recognize
and protect womens rights and interests? Will women be enabled
to influence and participate in the political process? (OECD gender
tipsheets)
B. Will social sector reform address womens
particular needs and concerns in an appropriate and adequate manner?
Will womens capacities and skills be recognized and incorporated
into the provision of social services? Will social reconstruction
generate socio-economic relationships that are advantageous to women?
(OECD gender tipsheets)
C. Does the security situation affect men and women differently?
Are women being targeted for certain violations? Are womens
and mens security issues known and concerns being met? Do
safe and accountable mechanisms for women to report and ensure redress
for violations they experience exist?
D. Are women included in transitional governments and planning processes?
Do women occupy decision-making positions? Do constitutional committees
ensure gender perspectives?
E. Do election processes involve women and men? Do men and women
have equal opportunity to vote and participate in elections? Are
a certain percentage of seats earmarked for men or women or other
groups? Are there capacity-building opportunities for women candidates
in local and national elections?
F. Are there efforts to build capacity of women and men so as they
can participate fully in governance and legal and judicial processes
?
G. Is sex-disaggregated information available on participation in
various committees or groups?
H. Are there plans to review the relevant legislation (e.g., inheritance
law, family code or credit regulations), policy (e.g., water, waste
disposal housing fee subsidy policy), and institutional framework
(e.g., current administrative system for concerned urban infrastructure
services) and the gender implications? (Asia Development Bank, checklist
on Urban Development)
9. Conflict prevention and reconciliation
A. Are womens human rights issues considered in reconstruction
and the establishment of a representative government? Are women
involved in truth and reconciliation processes? What mechanisms
for gender- sensitive redress for victims of armed conflict are
in place?
B. What have been the different roles of men and women, boys and
girls during conflict? What are their different perceptions of the
causes of conflict and how does this vary by region?
C. How have men and women, boys and girls been affected differently
by the conflict? What are their particular vulnerabilities, responses
and coping-mechanisms, and how does this vary by region?
D. How have the roles and responsibilities of men, women, boys and
girls changed during the last ten-year crisis-period? What new needs
have been created and how are these being addressed? What new opportunities
have been created and how are these being supported?
E. Do women and men have equal opportunity to contribute to peace-building
efforts at local, national and international levels? Do they have
equal access to capacity building for peace building and other skills
building initiatives?
F. Do women and men have access to capacity building for peace building
and other skills building initiatives?
10. Cultural Heritage
A. How can womens contributions to cultural heritage be safeguarded
and promulgated? What is the working status of women in the arts
and cultural sector?
B. What roles have women played in political history and how can
these be remembered and utilized effectively in developing a representative
government?
C. What were womens contributions to preserving cultural heritage
and how can these be supported? How can women's presence in and
contribution to cultural life as a whole be furthered?
D. How have men and women been portrayed differently throughout
cultural history, and what role can the UN play in ensuring the
representation of all people in cultural documentation and preservation?
E. What cultural knowledge resides with women and how can the continued
transmission of that knowledge be ensured? How can society make
full use of the wealth of talent, expression and experience contributed
by its people throughout the ages, regardless of their gender?
F. Do women have access to decision-making positions in cultural
policy, the arts and the media?
G. Is the production, dissemination, and accessibility of information
freely available to all Iraqis, regardless of their gender?
H. How can international norms and standards, including those that
promote gender equity, be highlighted in literature (including textbooks
and curricula)?
I. Does the measure of economic productivity take into account examples
of productivity in the arts, cultural education and the media--
specifically women's creative contributions to these fields?
12. Electricity, Port, Roads and Urban Development and Housing
A. Have both women's and mens needs been considered when designing
the infrastructure?
B. Has consideration been given to the tasks which are currently
undertaken by women and men that could be affected, such as transport
of food and other goods to the market, fuel and water collection?
Will the location of transport-related infrastructure affect women's
marketing of goods and other income-generating activities?
13. Private Sector Development
A. How has the economic situation affected women and men? Have women
and men experienced changes in the type of work, earning power,
access to loans and credit or land?
B. . How can the erosion of past gains regarding womens access
to land, property and wealth be avoided?
C. How do women save? How can womens savings be supported?
D. Are skills building opportunities available to men and women?
14. Environment and Natural Resources
A. How does exploitation of natural resources impact on womens
and mens subsistence livelihoods? What role do women play
in the production cycle?
B. How does exposure to environmental pollution and degradation
of the environment impact on womens and mens health
and livelihoods? How does the negative health impacts on the family
affect womens labor, time use and educational and career opportunities?
C. Are women legally and or traditionally recognized as managers
of natural resources? For which natural resources are women primarily
responsible? (OECD gender tipsheets) What impact has land reform
or policy had on womens access to land for food or cash crops?
D. What are the demographics of IDP populations? How have they adapted
in areas to which they were displaced (differential access, roles
and responsibilities)?
15. Mine Action Capacity and Mine Clearance
A. Do communications strategies consider outreach to women and girls?
(OECD gender tipsheets)
B. Are womens organizations mobilized to provide awareness
raising and public information on unexploded ordinance and landmines?
(OECD gender tipsheets)
C. Is medical assistance biased? Is priority given to military personnel
(most often male) while civilian casualties often take longer to
reach medical services? Does gender segregation result in slower
emergencies services to women? (OECD gender tipsheets)
D. Who cares for victims of landmines? Are caretakers receiving
adequate support? Are women and girls providing for the injured
immediately following the injury and providing long-term support?
In relation to the longer-term care implications: (OECD gender tipsheets)
E. Do landmine injuries affect women and men differently? For example,
does an amputee have fewer chances for marriage? Do spouses have
grounds for divorcing landmine victims due to their injuries? (OECD
gender tipsheets)
16. Disarmament, Demobilization and Reintegration (DDR)
A. Who is demobilized and who is retained as part of the restructured
force? Do women have the same right to choose to be demobilized
as men?
B. Is there sustainable funding to ensure the long-term success
of the DDR process? Are special funds allocated to women, and if
not, what measures are in place to ensure that their needs will
receive proper attention?
C. Is there commitment to establish a quote of women and peace negotiations?
Are women fighters adequately represented? Do existing veterans'
associations recognize women's needs?
D. Are mechanisms in place to ensure the recognition and political
participation of female ex-combatants after elections? Are women
equipped to participate in these processes? Are women equipped to
participate in democratic, civil and political structures and supported
in their political activities?
E. Has the support of local, regional and national women's organizations
been enlisted to aid reintegration? Has the collaboration of women
leaders in assisting ex-combatants and widows returning to civilian
life been enlisted? Are existing women's organizations being trained
to understand the needs and experiences of ex-combatants?
F. If a social security system exists, can women ex-combatants easily
access it? Does it target their needs and promote their skills?
G. Can the economy support the kind of training women might ask
for during the demobilization period? Have obstacles, such as narrow
expectations of women's work, been taken into account?
H. Do women have the right to chose where they will live in resettlement
programmes? Are women's particular security needs recognized when
planning transport home?
I. Do training packages offered to women reflect local gender norms
and standards about gender-appropriate behavior or does training
attempt to expand them? Does this benefit or hinder women's economic
independence?
J. What are women's specific health and psychological needs in the
context of demobilization? Are they different than men's needs?
K. Is there an awareness of sexualized violence against women combatants,
both during the conflict and after? Are there facilities for treatment,
counseling and protection?
L. Are single or widowed female ex-combatants recognized as heads
of households and permitted access to housing and land? Are legal
measures in place to protect their access to land and water?
M. What measures can be taken to avoid stigmatization of economically
active women, especially those who have also served in combat?
N. What measures are being taken to address women's security in
urban areas?
|